Spee-Dee 3800 vs. VTOPS-P2: A Professional Comparison of Two Servo Auger Filling Machines
In the powder packaging industry, servo-driven auger fillers have become essential for ensuring precision, hygiene, and production efficiency. This article provides a professional and neutral comparison between two competitive models in this segment: the Spee-Dee 3800 Series from the United States and the VTOPS-P2 from China. By examining their performance, control systems, construction, and application scope, we aim to help buyers choose the solution best suited to their operational needs.
1. Technical Overview
| Feature | Spee-Dee 3800 Series | VTOPS-P2 |
|---|---|---|
| Country of Origin | United States | China |
| Drive Mechanism | Direct-drive Servo-motor | Stepper-motor (Standard) Servo-motor (Optional) |
| Filling System | Filling by volume | Filling by Volume Filling by Weight Filling by Time (Interval time) |
| Filling Range | Typically 10g – 5,000g | 5g – 5,000g |
| Filling Accuracy | ±1% standard Up to ±0.25% with ideal conditions |
±1% (Fill-by-Volume) Up to ±0.3% (Fill-by-Weight) |
| Filling Speed | Up to ~60 fills/min | Up to ~60 fills/min (Servo) |
| Hopper Capacity | 10 gallons or 20 gallons | 50L standard; 100L optional |
| Material Contact | 304 stainless steel; hygienic design | 304 stainless steel; cGMP compliant |
2. Control & Integration
| Category | Spee-Dee 3800 Series | VTOPS-P2 |
|---|---|---|
| Control System | Allen-Bradley PLC + Maple Systems HMI | Delta PLC + Delta HMI |
| Multilingual | Yes | English, German, Spanish, French, Russian, Chinese |
| Integration | Easily integrates with VFFS, HFFS, rotary lines | Not Integrable |
| Changeover Time | Tool-less changeover; fast setup | Modular auger system; quick-change augers |
3. Application Suitability
| Material Type | Spee-Dee 3800 | VTOPS-P2 |
|---|---|---|
| Free-flowing powders | ✅ | ✅ |
| Non-free-flowing (e.g. protein, flour) | ✅ | ✅ |
| Dust-prone or hygroscopic powders | ✅ (with dust management) | ✅ (with dust collection optional) |
| Small granules (e.g. coffee, spice) | ✅ | ✅ |
4. Maintenance & Operation
| Category | Spee-Dee 3800 | VTOPS-P2 |
|---|---|---|
| Build Quality | Heavy-duty frame with quick-connects | Industrial-grade build with modular design |
| Cleaning | Tool-free disassembly; Sanitary construction | Tool-free disassembly; Easy-clean hopper |
| Support & Training | U.S.-based on-site and remote support | Global support + video remote assistance |
| Customization | High (integrator-ready) | High (supports hopper, foot pedal, accessories) |
5. Video Gallery
1000g Vitamin Powder Auger Filling Machine Fill-By-Weight | VTOPS-P2
224g Nutritional Powder Auger Filler with Bottle Clamp Device – VTOPS-P2 (Three Filling System)
200g Flour Dry Powder Auger Filling Machine Fill By Weight System Semi-Automatic Powder Auger Filler
6. Cost Efficiency & ROI
| Metric | Spee-Dee 3800 | VTOPS-P2 |
|---|---|---|
| Price Range | $15,000 – $30,000+ (USD) | $2,000 – $5,000 (USD) |
| ROI Cycle | Medium to long-term | Short-term |
| Target User Profile | Large-scale automation users | Small and medium-scale users |
7. Conclusion: Spee-Dee 3800 vs. VTOPS-P2 which One Fits Your Needs?
- Choose Spee-Dee 3800 if you operate a high-volume, fully automated production line and need North American support, superior build quality, and integration flexibility.
- Choose VTOPS-P2 if you’re a cost-conscious SME or exporter seeking servo precision, flexibility, and strong support at a competitive price point.
Both machines offer excellent filling accuracy and versatility. The final choice depends on your budget, integration needs, and support preferences.
Zhengzhou Vtops Machinery Co., Ltd.
ManufacturerAuger Filler Machine Capper Machine Checkweigher Induction Sealer Machine Labeler Vibratory Filler Vertical Form Fill Seal Multihead Weigher Packaging Machines Milk Powder Canning Line Horizontal Ribbon Blender
- 📅 Founded: 2001
- 🌐 Website
- China 🇨🇳
- Company Profile
📍 Address: Building 2, Dianchang Road 70, High-Tech Industrial Development Zone, Zhengzhou, 450000, China.
📄 Manufacturer Overview
Zhengzhou Vtops Machinery Co., Ltd. was founded in 2001, VTOPS is a manufacturer with a modern 40,000-square-meter facility and is one of the top three auger filler manufacturers in China.
Spee-Dee Packaging Machinery, Inc.
ManufacturerAuger Filler Machine
- 📅 Founded: 1981
- 🌐 Website
- United States 🇺🇸
- Company Profile
📍 Address: 1360 Grandview Pkwy, Sturtevant, Wisconsin, 53177, United States.
📄 Manufacturer Overview
Spee-Dee Packaging Machinery, Inc. is a family-owned company based in Sturtevant, Wisconsin, USA, specializing in the design and manufacturing of packaging machinery. Founded in 1981 by Jim Navin, the company offers a range of solutions including volumetric cup fillers, auger fillers, rigid container fillers, and checkweighers, serving industries such as food, pharmaceuticals, and chemicals.
